How To Choose The BEST Tenant FAST 🏡 (Without Getting Burned!)

How To Choose The BEST Tenant FAST 🏡 (Without Getting Burned!)
Picking the right tenant is EVERYTHING. Here's the smart, simple checklist that gets you great tenants — and protects your rental!
Pick The Best Tenant Without Regret
The wrong tenant can cost you thousands. Damage, nonpayment, legal battles — nightmare. But the right tenant? Smooth cash flow, zero drama, peace of mind. Here’s exactly how to screen, select, and lock in awesome tenants — FAST.
Step 1: Set Your Minimum Standards (Before You List)
Before you even advertise, decide your non-negotiables:
- Minimum credit score (example: 650+)
- Minimum income (at least 3x monthly rent)
- No recent evictions or bankruptcies
- Good references from previous landlords
Write these down and stick to them. No exceptions for "gut feelings." Consistency protects you legally too.
Step 2: Use A Clear, Professional Listing
A vague listing = bad applicants. A clear listing = pre-screened quality. Include:
- Rent amount
- Deposit requirements
- Pet policy
- Required background/credit checks
Quality tenants expect these details — and will appreciate your professionalism.
Step 3: Pre-Screen Before Showing
Don’t waste time showing your property to everyone. Ask basic pre-screen questions first:
- "When would you like to move in?"
- "How many people would be living in the home?"
- "Do you have pets?"
- "Can you verify your monthly income?"
Friendly but firm. Saves you hours and headaches.
Step 4: Use A Solid Rental Application
Online applications make life easier. Use platforms like Zillow, RentRedi, or Avail to collect:
- Full name, SSN, DOB
- Rental history and references
- Employment and income info
- Consent for credit/criminal background checks
No app = no screening = no tenancy.
Step 5: Screen Like A Detective
Run background checks. Run credit reports. Verify employment directly (call HR if needed). CALL previous landlords (don't just email). Listen carefully:
- If they hesitate when you ask, "Would you rent to them again?" — big red flag.
Step 6: Trust But Verify
Paystubs can be faked. Bank statements can be edited. If something feels weird, dig deeper or move on. A tiny "off" feeling during screening often saves you thousands later.
Step 7: Pick The Best Fit — Not The First Applicant
Desperation leads to bad choices. Wait for a strong, fully-qualified applicant. Renting to the first warm body costs way more in the long run.
Real Example:
One property I managed had 14 applications. 5 were "ok," but 2 were exceptional — 700+ credit scores, long stable employment, awesome references. I chose quality — and that tenant stayed for 4 years with zero issues. $48,000+ in rent collected, no damages, no evictions.
Final Thoughts
Finding great tenants isn’t luck — it’s a SYSTEM. Set clear standards. Pre-screen smart. Verify everything. Never rush. The right tenant is worth every extra hour of screening. Protect your rental, protect your peace, and protect your profits!
Related Blog
- 03/18/2025 4-min read
How To KEEP Your Best Tenants Longer (And Avoid Expensive Vacancies!)
Keeping good tenants is WAY cheaper than finding new ones. Here's how to make tenants stay — and love it!
Read More- 05/26/2025 3-min read
Creative Ways To Monetise Unused Spaces In Your Rental Property
Extra storage, garages, and even your driveway can bring in income. Here’s how to turn dead space into real dollars.
Read More